Are Fishing Expeditions Allowed At Depositions?


Deposition Defined with law book
Deposition Defined with a law book

The first thing you must know about the discovery process called depositions are the types of questions that are allowed. You must answer even the most irrelevant questions. And you must also answer compound, disjunctive, conjunctive, asked and answered, or even lack foundation, etc. These types of questions could be fishing expeditions where you are asked questions that don't even relate to the actual incident.

The reasoning is that the question's answer may lead to other evidence or witnesses with information that is admissible during trial. So the other side can object and preserve it for trial, but you must answer whether you are the personal injury plaintiff or defendant. For example, in a car accident case, for example, you can still use unverified written discovery to impeach the character of your witness.

What Can They Ask You?

During civil discovery, fishing expeditions are allowed. But sometimes no response at all is ok. But this is when the Constitution or some privacy statute comes into play. Your attorney will tell you what to do. So the exceptions would be if the information is:

  • Private
  • Privileged
  • Confidential.

This remains true even if it is a tag team style deposition with multiple parties. But the opposing side can request a privilege log. And this is done to see what is being withheld. Then the judge can decide in camera if there is a substantial likelihood that this evidence is helpful and a low burden of harming any privileges. For most lawyers, no matter how long they have practiced law, depositions are time-consuming and accompanied by threats and a lot of stress. No matter what, the defense attorney needs to get answers to a few specific items, and so does the plaintiff, you.

Why is Your Credibility so Key at Your Deposition?

Always at issue is your credibility. In some cases, a jury may find in favor of a plaintiff and only award a dollar because he or she is a jerk. Usually, this has to do with the defense tearing the plaintiff a new one during discovery. Locking the plaintiff into a false or dishonest answer, or getting a plaintiff to change the answer has been the death knell for many a personal injury case. Plaintiff's lawyer must be prepared for any contingency.

For example, your lawyer must know how to deal with questions regarding prior similar accidents and injuries. This helps prove nightclub assaults and slip and fall cases, for example. But if the plaintiff lies about their past criminal history, illnesses, lawsuits, work history, treatments, and records of treatment, this can kill their case. Credibility is an issue always.


Plaintiffs should answer as follows:

  • "I don't remember, " "I don't recall."
  • "Yes."
  • "No."
  • "I don't know."
  • "In front." (For example. Q: "Where were you?" A: "In front.").

No requirement forces you to volunteer information. After all, you cannot answer something you if you don't know. Honesty is the only requirement. Obviously, the attorney you hire must teach and counsel you the process. But even if your lawyer objects, in most cases, you must answer the question.

Sometimes, failure to respond results in "Doomsday Sanctions." These sanctions include the issue and terminating sanctions. Termination of whole defenses and cases could be an issue.

Who can help You In a Personal Injury Deposition?

The experienced accident attorneys at Ehline Law Firm Personal Injury Attorneys, APLC are committed to holding negligent people accountable for their action. Our studious lawyers know the applicable discovery laws. Plus, we have extensive experience taking on these types of claims.

The benefit to you is that you can leverage our negotiating skills and talent. When you or a loved one wants to win maximum compensation after a bad accident, call our office today. Reach out now for a free consultation. If you cannot call, complete the contact form here on our website.

How Much is My Case Worth?

Fist full of personal injury dollars
American dollars in the hands.
Please use any of our easy contact us methods for your free case evaluation. Don’t let the statute of limitations expire in your case. Time is of the essence.

Do I Need a Lawyer?


We make it Happen
We make it happen. “Do or Die”
The deal is, you need a lawyer in order to safeguard your legal rights. Plus, you can assure you obtain reasonable compensation for your losses arising from your accident. Since we offer a free legal consultation, why not contact us now to discuss the intricacies of your case in confidence with a fine tooth comb? We are standing by! Protect Your Rights With Our Handy ACCIDENT REPORT Now!

ATTORNEY ADVERTISEMENT and Public Use information. 844-WIN-CASE is not intended to imply or infer that ELFPI casn win every case. Every case is unique, as eaach person. No reasonable person could assume every case is win-able. The data on this website is generated by a member of the State Bar of California to provide general information and to answer the most frequently asked questions regarding tort law, and/or negligence claims. Parts herein contain attorney marketing information. Other parts do not. However, nothing on this website shall be construed as legal advice for any legal matter, or non-legal matter. Nor does anything on this website form a contract, or attorney-client alliance. (Read more.)

© 2019 Ehline Law Firm, Personal Injury Attorneys, A Professional Law Corporation. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.